In an interview on Pod Save America, host Dan Pfeiffer asked Pete Buttigieg a simple question. “Are there one or two issues where Pete Buttigieg disagrees with the mainstream Democratic party view?”
A quick reminder, in case you forgot: Just two weeks ago, the Democratic Party won votes in corners of the country previously thought unwinnable. Several state legislatures flipped and brought Democratic trifectas in key states. Voters from the mountains of Maine to the marshes of Mississippi gave the U.S. Senate a Democratic mandate with the “biggest haul of Senate seats in a single election since 1980.” An affordability crisis driven by useless tariffs and a war in Iran had Black voters in Michigan ready to embrace socialism and white Christian evangelicals in Texas cheering for proposals to tax Elon Musk.
But rather than ride the blue tsunami and make good on the demands of a broad electorate, Pete opted to take a jab at an indebted working class.
“We really over-torqued on the student loan thing, as a party,” said Buttigieg. “I have a very hard time explaining to my relatives in Michigan who did not go to college why they should be paying for people who do. I believe there are ways to make sure that you come out of college debt free. I believe college should be more affordable. I don’t believe in a magic wand to fix that for everybody who borrowed money.”
Nevermind that voters in Michigan just sent Abdul El-Sayed to the U.S. Senate by seven points (sounds like an even tougher conversation for Pete’s relatives), it’s telling—first of all—that Pete refers to the federal government’s attempt to fix an economic crisis that burdens 45 million Americans and their families as some “thing,” as if it were an incel-driven culture war snafu of the week instead of the literal kitchen table issue that it is.
$2 trillion in crushing student debt has rendered the masses unable to purchase a home, start a family, save for retirement, open a small business or live a life with dignity. In a 2021 survey, 40% of Black voters said they would consider sitting out the next election if there were no action on student debt. In a 2024 presidential debate with Kamala Harris, Trump took a swipe at Harris and Biden for “taunting” student debtors — not for the student debt Biden successfully canceled, but for what he didn’t cancel despite promising voters broad action on the issue. Shortly before the 2026 midterm election, Trump even signaled he would be open to pausing student debt or signing legislation to cap the high interest. But Pete? Not him. The “student loan thing” was too far for him, putting him firmly to the political right of Biden, and by some accounts, Trump.
It’s not just that Pete is riding against the tide of populism with this remark. Pete is simply wrong on the substance here — and his outdated talking points make him sound less like a top contender for the 2028 Democratic ticket and more like a fellow at the Heritage Foundation (although both may poll at 0% with Black voters). Student debt cancellation isn’t paid for by the nation’s taxpayers (nevermind that student debtors are taxpayers). That’s just not how student debt cancellation works. Canceling a debt doesn’t cost money because the money has already gone out the door when the loan was issued — it’s not the same as handing out cash. The federal government has a bevy of cancellation programs fixed into its model with the understanding that trapping workers in full-on debtors prisons might raise some constitutional issues. Ironically, it is student debtors that have forked over all the cash, in which millions of student debtors—teachers, nurses, firefighters and social workers—have actually paid much more than they originally borrowed, but are still stuck with ballooning interest and a cloud over their heads.
If Pete is so disgusted by a class of people getting debt cancellation while others twiddle their thumbs, perhaps he should read up on the billions of PPP loans canceled during COVID-19, or revisit the details of the 2008 financial collapse.
Buttigieg is well known for his wit, intelligence and quick-footed thinking, which is what makes his response so infuriating. Can Pete have a substantive deviation from the Democratic Party? Of course! Many would likely welcome it. Pete could have voiced his support for structural changes to our Supreme Court or judicial system. He could have announced that as President, he would ban stock trading or Flock cameras. Instead, Pete decided to make an enemy out of working people while simultaneously pitting them against one another.
At minimum, student debtors need a President in 2028 that understands the various legal authorities that allow them to cancel student debt. They need a President that understands the federal government doesn’t budget like a household and won’t go broke if student debt is canceled or paused for three years like it was under both Trump and Biden. But more than that, student debtors need a champion. Someone who will use their bully pulpit to make the case to the American people that our universities are laboratories of democracy, and people shouldn’t be financially punished for having enrolled in one. That student debt cancellation makes good on the promise of Lyndon B Johnson — and pushes back on the failures of Ronald Reagan. That the fastest rising group of student debtors, Americans over the age of 62, deserve a Social Security check that won’t be garnished and a little more financial breathing room, not an illegal crew of debt collectors knocking on their doors.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has been able to persuade President Trump to release detained immigrants and delay harmful SNAP cuts. Senator Warren was able to work with Republicans to put a bill on Trump’s desk to prevent private equity from buying up single family homes. Student debt shouldn’t be another political football 2028 presidential candidates toss around to see what sticks. If Pete is incapable of explaining to his relatives in Michigan that student debt cancellation is good for the economy, narrows the racial wealth gap, creates jobs and allows almost a sixth of our nation to live with a bit of dignity, perhaps he just has a skill issue.





We MUST hold Dems accountable. We truly don’t care what the Party says or does. Elected officials work for us - that’s what elections are for - and it’s time to remind them. They do not, in fact, work for the Party. My husband and I finally paid off all our student debt a decade ago and we’d be jumping for joy if folks who have this debt today get some relief from it.
You should start a letter for everyone to sign including what you wrote in the article about Buttigieg’s comments. Send it to him so he knows we all heard him. I will never vote for him knowing his ignorance and lack of care for regular people who just wanted to go to college. There was a magic wand for all those PPE loans, but no wand for student debt. Buttigieg should know he is alienating millions with that comment.